Image 1 of 1
Red Lip Theology — Candice Marie Benbow | Book Club Discussion Guide
Red Lip Theology is part memoir, part theology, and entirely testimony. Candice Benbow is building her faith from the fullness of her actual life rather than from the life the church told her she should be living. From the beauty supply store. From Beyoncé. From her queer friends. From her own desire. From her grief. From the red lipstick that Black women have always worn as armor and dignity, and the refusal to be diminished. She is not asking to leave Christianity. She is asking to claim it in its entirety, as a Black woman whose life has been her most honest theological text.
This kit was built for the room that knows exactly what Benbow is talking about. For the woman who is still in the pew and still carrying questions the church never made space for. For the woman who left and is still sorting out what she took with her. For the woman who finished this book thinking about her mother — or her grandmother, or her church mother, or her mentor — and the specific cost that woman paid to pass on faith to her. All three women are in this room. All three deserve space to speak without being managed toward a conclusion.
The discussion will be divided. Not between people who love the church and people who don't — that divide is too simple for what Benbow is doing. It will divide women at different points in their own faith journeys, holding different things from the same institution, with varying levels of peace about what they hold. Both the prosecution and the defense of the Black church are in this kit. Neither is dismissed. The goal is not a verdict. The goal is the honest examination Benbow is modeling — holding up what you were given and deciding consciously what belongs to you.
A note on audience: This guide was written specifically for Black women who have experienced the Black church. It engages Benbow's arguments directly — including her arguments about sexuality, purity culture, and the LGBTQIA+ community — without softening them for a general audience. Please consider your group's readiness for this material before purchasing.
What's Inside:
✦ Content Warning — The shame of unmarried motherhood in the Black church — Sexual shame and purity culture — LGBTQIA+ identity and institutional rejection — Grief and unexpected loss — The specific harm of being told by a faith community that who you are is not acceptable to God
✦ About This Book — Not a systematic theology and not a manifesto — A testimony service in essay form — A mother who kept giving her daughter God through an institution that used God against both of them — The red lip as armor and dignity and the refusal to be diminished — Built for the room that knows exactly what Benbow is talking about
✦ What This Book Is Really About — On the surface / Underneath — The shame asymmetry — the church finds the person it can see and it can always see the woman — What a mother passes to her daughter through a faith that has also hurt her — Grief as the test that reveals what actually holds — The sacred in the spaces the church says God is not
✦ Discussion Questions — Three Tiers — Tier 1: Entry points including the humor that opens what solemnity cannot — Tier 2: Make the case both ways — queer friendships as theological necessity, refusing shame versus building a theology, finding God in secular spaces, grief as teacher or distortion, the difference between what Debra gave and what the church gave — Tier 3: Personal uncomfortable unresolvable — Closes with: What question did this book refuse to answer?
✦ Character on Trial — The Shame of the Unmarried Mother: what the shame was actually protecting and who it was actually serving — The Faith Debra Gave Candice: the same faith grown into fullness or two faiths that share a root but grew in different directions — The Red Lip Theology: permission without direction or the prerequisite for everything else — No neutral positions allowed — Final synthesis: is what Benbow built enough to pass to the next generation the way Debra passed hers to Candice
✦ Activities — The Inheritance Audit: one thing keeping and one thing examining named out loud — The Testimony: one sentence true about your experience of God or the church that the church never made space for read aloud — The Mother: name the woman name the gift name what she paid — The Personal Reckoning: where you are right now in your relationship with the Black church — Verdict Vote: is the faith Debra gave and the faith Candice built the same faith — and is what Benbow built enough to pass on
✦ Quote Prompts — Six prompts six emotional entry points — The passage that made you laugh first and what the laughter opened — The Debra passage where she was most herself — The body passage and what it stirred — The passage where you found God somewhere the church said God was not — The sentence that has stayed with you — The passage that made you think of a specific woman in your life and what she paid
✦ Spoiler Corner — Host only — Full knowledge of the entire book required — What Debra's faithfulness reveals about what she actually believed about God on her own terms — The humor as theological position and as protective distance — Benbow's ending as invitation versus what the church owes the women who kept showing up
✦ For the Host — Three fault lines: where each woman is in her relationship with the church the mother thread and the LGBTQIA+ argument — Special guidance for rooms still fully inside the church — Special guidance for rooms that have largely left — The Testimony as the great equalizer — Timing flow for a single session
Details: Instant download — PDF format — Personal and single-group use — Fan-created discussion guide — Not affiliated with or endorsed by Candice Marie Benbow or any publisher — 20+ pages print-ready
Content note: This guide discusses the shame of unmarried motherhood in the Black church, sexual shame and purity culture, LGBTQIA+ identity and institutional rejection, and grief and unexpected loss. This guide was written specifically for Black women who have experienced the Black church. Please consider your group's readiness for this material before purchasing.
Licensing for classrooms, seminaries, and faith community programs is available. If you plan to use this guide for a class ministry program or institutional setting, please contact the shop owner to arrange an appropriate license.
This kit was built for the room that finished Red Lip Theology and needed somewhere to put everything the book left in them. It was built for the conversation that starts with what the church cost the women who kept showing up and ends somewhere none of you expected.
Red Lip Theology is part memoir, part theology, and entirely testimony. Candice Benbow is building her faith from the fullness of her actual life rather than from the life the church told her she should be living. From the beauty supply store. From Beyoncé. From her queer friends. From her own desire. From her grief. From the red lipstick that Black women have always worn as armor and dignity, and the refusal to be diminished. She is not asking to leave Christianity. She is asking to claim it in its entirety, as a Black woman whose life has been her most honest theological text.
This kit was built for the room that knows exactly what Benbow is talking about. For the woman who is still in the pew and still carrying questions the church never made space for. For the woman who left and is still sorting out what she took with her. For the woman who finished this book thinking about her mother — or her grandmother, or her church mother, or her mentor — and the specific cost that woman paid to pass on faith to her. All three women are in this room. All three deserve space to speak without being managed toward a conclusion.
The discussion will be divided. Not between people who love the church and people who don't — that divide is too simple for what Benbow is doing. It will divide women at different points in their own faith journeys, holding different things from the same institution, with varying levels of peace about what they hold. Both the prosecution and the defense of the Black church are in this kit. Neither is dismissed. The goal is not a verdict. The goal is the honest examination Benbow is modeling — holding up what you were given and deciding consciously what belongs to you.
A note on audience: This guide was written specifically for Black women who have experienced the Black church. It engages Benbow's arguments directly — including her arguments about sexuality, purity culture, and the LGBTQIA+ community — without softening them for a general audience. Please consider your group's readiness for this material before purchasing.
What's Inside:
✦ Content Warning — The shame of unmarried motherhood in the Black church — Sexual shame and purity culture — LGBTQIA+ identity and institutional rejection — Grief and unexpected loss — The specific harm of being told by a faith community that who you are is not acceptable to God
✦ About This Book — Not a systematic theology and not a manifesto — A testimony service in essay form — A mother who kept giving her daughter God through an institution that used God against both of them — The red lip as armor and dignity and the refusal to be diminished — Built for the room that knows exactly what Benbow is talking about
✦ What This Book Is Really About — On the surface / Underneath — The shame asymmetry — the church finds the person it can see and it can always see the woman — What a mother passes to her daughter through a faith that has also hurt her — Grief as the test that reveals what actually holds — The sacred in the spaces the church says God is not
✦ Discussion Questions — Three Tiers — Tier 1: Entry points including the humor that opens what solemnity cannot — Tier 2: Make the case both ways — queer friendships as theological necessity, refusing shame versus building a theology, finding God in secular spaces, grief as teacher or distortion, the difference between what Debra gave and what the church gave — Tier 3: Personal uncomfortable unresolvable — Closes with: What question did this book refuse to answer?
✦ Character on Trial — The Shame of the Unmarried Mother: what the shame was actually protecting and who it was actually serving — The Faith Debra Gave Candice: the same faith grown into fullness or two faiths that share a root but grew in different directions — The Red Lip Theology: permission without direction or the prerequisite for everything else — No neutral positions allowed — Final synthesis: is what Benbow built enough to pass to the next generation the way Debra passed hers to Candice
✦ Activities — The Inheritance Audit: one thing keeping and one thing examining named out loud — The Testimony: one sentence true about your experience of God or the church that the church never made space for read aloud — The Mother: name the woman name the gift name what she paid — The Personal Reckoning: where you are right now in your relationship with the Black church — Verdict Vote: is the faith Debra gave and the faith Candice built the same faith — and is what Benbow built enough to pass on
✦ Quote Prompts — Six prompts six emotional entry points — The passage that made you laugh first and what the laughter opened — The Debra passage where she was most herself — The body passage and what it stirred — The passage where you found God somewhere the church said God was not — The sentence that has stayed with you — The passage that made you think of a specific woman in your life and what she paid
✦ Spoiler Corner — Host only — Full knowledge of the entire book required — What Debra's faithfulness reveals about what she actually believed about God on her own terms — The humor as theological position and as protective distance — Benbow's ending as invitation versus what the church owes the women who kept showing up
✦ For the Host — Three fault lines: where each woman is in her relationship with the church the mother thread and the LGBTQIA+ argument — Special guidance for rooms still fully inside the church — Special guidance for rooms that have largely left — The Testimony as the great equalizer — Timing flow for a single session
Details: Instant download — PDF format — Personal and single-group use — Fan-created discussion guide — Not affiliated with or endorsed by Candice Marie Benbow or any publisher — 20+ pages print-ready
Content note: This guide discusses the shame of unmarried motherhood in the Black church, sexual shame and purity culture, LGBTQIA+ identity and institutional rejection, and grief and unexpected loss. This guide was written specifically for Black women who have experienced the Black church. Please consider your group's readiness for this material before purchasing.
Licensing for classrooms, seminaries, and faith community programs is available. If you plan to use this guide for a class ministry program or institutional setting, please contact the shop owner to arrange an appropriate license.
This kit was built for the room that finished Red Lip Theology and needed somewhere to put everything the book left in them. It was built for the conversation that starts with what the church cost the women who kept showing up and ends somewhere none of you expected.